Skip to content
OHA

Return to work after mental health leave: the employee's right, the team's load

Ontario law asks an employer to accommodate a return from mental health leave to the point of undue hardship and, where there is a WSIB claim, to meet WSIB's return-to-work duties. Neither measures the load the return puts on the manager and the team.

, OHA Wellness

Published · Updated · Practice · 7 min

Two colleagues reviewing a return to work planner
A return from mental health leave has two sides: the duty owed to the person coming back, and the load carried by the people around them.

The short answer

Under Ontario's Human Rights Code the employer must accommodate the returning employee to the point of undue hardship, and the OHRC says the person generally has the right to return to the pre-disability job. Where there is a WSIB claim, WSIB's return-to-work policies apply as well.

On this page
  1. What does Ontario law require on a return from mental health leave?
  2. How long must a job be held open, and can a return plan be fixed?
  3. What changes when the return follows a WSIB claim?
  4. What does a return do to the team around the employee?
  5. What should a manager do in the first weeks after a return?
  6. What OHA does about this
  7. Sources

Return to work after mental health leave in Ontario runs on one legal duty for every employer and, where there is a WSIB claim, a second. The Human Rights Code requires the employer to accommodate the returning employee to the point of undue hardship, and the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) says a person who returns after a disability-related absence generally has the right to go back to the job held before.

Those duties describe what the employer owes the person coming back. In OHA's reading, what a return does to the manager who plans it and the colleagues who cover the work is mostly left to the workplace. Statistics Canada's 2022 Canadian Survey on Disability found that, among adults aged 25 to 64 with a disability, 46% had a mental health-related disability.

What does Ontario law require on a return from mental health leave?

The Human Rights Code requires the employer to accommodate the returning employee to the point of undue hardship. The OHRC says the Code covers an employee who returns to work after a disability-related absence, and that the duty to accommodate a mental health disability is no less rigorous than the duty to accommodate a physical one.

The OHRC's Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability, revised in 2016, says such a person generally has the right to return to the pre-disability job, if they can carry out its essential duties after accommodation short of undue hardship. If they cannot, the employer still has to canvass alternative work. When the employee asks to be reinstated, the employer must make the appropriate inquiries into whether they can carry out the essential functions, and the employee must be given an opportunity to prove they can.

The Code allows only three considerations in judging undue hardship: cost, outside sources of funding and health and safety requirements. The OHRC says no others can be taken into account, and that business inconvenience and employee morale are not valid considerations.

How long must a job be held open, and can a return plan be fixed?

The Code sets no fixed rule on how long an employee may be absent before the duty to accommodate has been met. The OHRC lists the predictability of the absence, how often it may recur and the prognosis as factors, and says the duty is more likely to continue where the prognosis is better.

The right is not unlimited. In a case about a 90-day rule that made any temporary restriction lasting longer permanent, the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario said the obligation to keep a job open generally extends for more than three months, limited by undue hardship. The OHRC adds that a return-to-work program built on arbitrary cut-offs, or on an inflexible return date, may be challenged under the Code, and that undue hardship remains the standard for judging such programs.

What changes when the return follows a WSIB claim?

A WSIB claim adds return-to-work duties. WSIB policy 19-02-08 sets out the employer's co-operation obligations: contact the worker early, keep communication going through the recovery, try to provide suitable work consistent with the worker's functional abilities and give WSIB all relevant return-to-work information. The same policy says the duty to modify work to the point of undue hardship comes from the Human Rights Code.

WSIB approves chronic or traumatic mental stress claims only when a qualified health professional has diagnosed a mental disorder using DSM-5 criteria and a work-related stressor or traumatic event is its primary cause. It says stress caused by regular management decisions, such as firing or transfers, is not covered. A Return-to-Work Specialist helps the worker go back to work or find suitable alternative work.

Re-employment is a separate obligation, set out in policy 19-02-09. It applies when the worker was unable to work because of the work-related injury or illness, had been continuously employed by the employer for at least a year before it, and the employer regularly employs 20 or more workers. It ends at the earliest of two years from the date of injury, one year after the worker is medically able to do the essential duties of the pre-injury job, and age 65. A worker who can do those duties must be offered the pre-injury position or comparable work at comparable earnings.

What does a return do to the team around the employee?

In OHA's reading, a return moves work onto the people who cover and decisions onto the manager who plans the return, and the law mostly addresses that through the employee's privacy and the employer's duty to deal with resentment. The OHRC says co-workers may have a role in helping with an accommodation, and that the employer should resolve tension or conflict caused by resentment among those expected to help. Its policy also cites a Tribunal adjudicator who accepted that accommodation can create these problems for management, but said they are not normally a legitimate consideration in an undue hardship analysis.

Research on returns after injury points to a related gap. In a 2009 summary of a Swedish study of three public-sector workplaces, based on 33 interviews, the Institute for Work & Health reported that co-workers supported and to an extent organized the day-to-day tasks of the returning injured worker, and that these efforts were sometimes invisible to supervisors. The study was qualitative, limited to the public sector and about injured workers in general.

In OHA's framework, this is where load moves. Emotional load rises for the manager who holds the employee's situation, the team's questions and their own concerns at once. Cognitive and decisional load rise for whoever covers the work and for the manager who decides who covers what. The post on the quiet signs of emotional load in a team shows what that looks like in a calendar, and the check below puts the Five Loads side by side for the team around a return.

Five Loads quick check · 1 minute

Find the load consuming your team's capacity.

Five statements, about a minute. See all five loads side by side. Answer for your own week, or for the team around a return: how often is each of these true?

Statement 1 of 5

I put off difficult conversations longer than I should.

What should a manager do in the first weeks after a return?

Start with what the OHRC lists for the employer: be alert to accommodation needs even without a formal request, accept the request in good faith, consult the person, communicate regularly, maintain confidentiality, keep a record and act in a timely way. In many organizations the manager does these things; that is OHA's reading of the list, not the OHRC's.

On medical documentation, the OHRC's position is that the information asked for should be functional, not a diagnosis. It says the information should cover the limitations or needs tied to the disability, whether the person can perform the essential duties with or without accommodation, the accommodation that may be needed and, for someone on leave, regular updates on the expected return. The focus should be on functional limitations rather than diagnosis, and the employer generally has no right to the diagnosis, symptoms or treatment unless they clearly relate to the accommodation sought or the person's needs are complex, challenging or unclear.

Then plan the cover as part of the return. A 2018 systematic review in the Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, covering 36 medium and high quality studies with searches to April 2015, found strong evidence that interventions combining at least two of health-focused care, service coordination and work modification reduced time away from work for workers with musculoskeletal, pain-related or mental health conditions (the review covers them together, not mental health alone), and moderate evidence of a positive effect on cost. OHA's view is that before the return date you should decide which tasks stay covered, who covers them and when you will review it. Tell colleagues what they need to know to help and no more, which is the OHRC's guidance on privacy. Our post on mental health training for managers and the room to use it covers the second half of that sentence, which is OHA's view: skill needs time to be used.

What OHA does about this

OHA's Capacity Diagnostic is built to measure the Five Loads across a team, including the managers and colleagues who carry a return, and to show which load weighs most. The results are designed to help HR and leaders decide where cover, decisions or approvals need attention, and they are measured again at 90 days inside OHA's Capacity Circle™. See how to book a Capacity Diagnostic.

Book a Capacity Diagnostic

Sources

  1. Statistics Canada, Canadian Survey on Disability, 2017 to 2022, The Daily, 1 December 2023 (2022 data).
  2. Ontario Human Rights Commission, Discrimination based on disability and the duty to accommodate..., 2024 (page dated by its 2024 copyright).
  3. Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on preventing discrimination based on mental health..., 2014 (section 13, Duty to accommodate).
  4. Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability, 27 June 2016 (section 8, Duty to accommodate).
  5. Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability, 27 June 2016 (section 9, Undue hardship).
  6. WSIB, RTW Co-operation Obligations, 20 July 2023 (policy 19-02-08).
  7. WSIB, Work-related mental stress injuries, Updated 26 March 2026.
  8. WSIB, Re-employment Obligations, 30 November 2020 (policy 19-02-09).
  9. Institute for Work & Health, Co-workers play important, but sometimes “invisible” role in RTW, January 2009 (Swedish study, 2009 summary).
  10. Ontario Human Rights Commission, OHRC policy position on medical documentation to be provided, 2024 (page dated by its 2024 copyright).
  11. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, Effectiveness of Workplace Interventions in Return-to-Work for..., 2018 (searches to April 2015).

Find out what is consuming your managers' capacity.

Tell us what your team needs. Caroline replies within one business day, in English or French.

We use these details only to answer your request. Privacy policy