Duty to accommodate mental health: do not wait for a request
The duty to accommodate a mental health condition comes from Ontario's Human Rights Code, or from the Canadian Human Rights Act for federally regulated employers, and runs to the point of undue hardship. What it asks of a manager while the employee is still at work, and what an accommodation does to the team.
OHA Team, OHA Wellness
Published · Updated · Practice · 7 min

The short answer
The duty to accommodate means adjusting the job or working conditions so an employee with a disability can keep working, to the point of undue hardship. It comes from Ontario's Human Rights Code, or from the Canadian Human Rights Act for federally regulated employers, and it does not wait for a formal request.
On this page
The duty to accommodate a mental health condition means adjusting the job or the working conditions so that an employee with a disability can keep working, to the point of undue hardship. In Ontario it comes from the Human Rights Code, and for federally regulated employers from the Canadian Human Rights Act (CHRA).
The Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) says the duty is no less rigorous for a mental health disability than for a physical one, and that it does not wait for a formal request. This post sets out, as the OHRC and the Canadian Human Rights Commission (CHRC) state it, what the duty asks of a manager while the employee is still at work. It is information, not legal advice: for a disputed case, call an employment lawyer.
What does the duty to accommodate require of an employer?
It requires the employer to adjust a requirement, rule or standard that adversely affects a person with a disability, unless doing so causes undue hardship. The OHRC's policy on ableism names sections 11 and 17 of the Code as the source. Under section 17, a person cannot be treated as unable to perform the essential duties of a job unless their needs cannot be accommodated without undue hardship. The OHRC adds that there is no set formula: each person's needs are assessed individually, and the accommodation should respect the person's dignity.
For a mental health disability, the OHRC's mental health policy lists forms of accommodation in employment: modifying job duties, alternative supervision arrangements, alternative ways of communicating with the employee, more training or training delivered differently, modified break policies, a flexible work schedule, job bundling and alternative work, and short-term and long-term disability leave.
For federally regulated employers the source is the CHRA. Section 15(1)(a) lets an employer defend a practice as a bona fide occupational requirement, and section 15(2) says that requires showing that accommodating the needs of the individual would impose undue hardship, considering health, safety and cost. The CHRC's guide for federally regulated workplaces, dated March 23, 2026, describes the duty as adjusting working conditions so that workers who are able to work are not unfairly excluded.
What counts as undue hardship?
In Ontario the Code allows only three considerations: cost, outside sources of funding, and health and safety requirements. The OHRC says business inconvenience, employee morale and customer and third-party preferences are not valid considerations, that costs must be quantifiable, related to the accommodation and so substantial that they would alter the essential nature of the enterprise or substantially affect its viability, and that the organization claiming undue hardship has the onus of showing it. For federally regulated employers, the CHRC's guide says there is no standard formula or precise legal definition of undue hardship, that it can be claimed only on grounds of cost, health or safety, and that a claim must rest on facts and evidence, not assumptions. Whether a particular accommodation reaches that point is a question for an employment lawyer.
Does the duty start only when an employee asks?
No. The OHRC says an accommodation provider must be alert to the possibility that a person needs accommodation even if they have not made a specific or formal request, and that a person with a mental health disability need not meet an onerous standard for first communicating that a disability exists. Where a person is clearly unwell or perceived to have a disability, the provider must attempt to help by inquiring about their needs. The OHRC quotes a Tribunal decision that an employer cannot passively wait for a request where it knows of facts suggesting difficulties due to a disability, and says a severe change in a person's behaviour could signal that a situation warrants further examination. The CHRC's guide says changes in attendance, performance or behaviour that are more sustained or dramatic in nature may trigger the employer's duty to inquire, and that the employer should not assume the cause and should be respectful, supportive and non-judgemental.
Before a measure that could affect the person negatively, the OHRC says an employer must assess each person individually, and that the disability must be a factor in deciding what sanctions, if any, are appropriate. In OHA's reading, this is where most managers meet the duty without a request: a deadline that slips, lateness that repeats, a change in how someone takes part in meetings. Our post on the quiet signs of emotional load in a team shows what that looks like in a calendar before anyone asks.
Five Loads quick check · 1 minute
Find the load consuming your team's capacity.
Five statements, about a minute. See all five loads side by side. Answer for your own week, or for a team where someone may need an accommodation: how often is each of these true?
Statement 1 of 5
What should a manager do while the employee is still at work?
In OHA's reading, the manager is usually the first person to meet the duty, so the steps below put the OHRC's and the CHRC's lists in a sequence that is OHA's; the sources do not fix an order. First, open a conversation about the work, not the diagnosis: the OHRC's mental health policy gives the example of a manager who asks an employee what they need to do well at work. The OHRC says information requested should cover the limitations or needs, whether the person can perform the essential duties with or without accommodation and the accommodation that may be needed, and that an employer generally cannot require the diagnosis, symptoms or treatment unless they clearly relate to the accommodation or the needs are complex or unclear. The CHRC says a worker does not have to disclose a diagnosis and that employers are very rarely entitled to a diagnosis or treatment plan.
Second, accept the request in good faith, consult the person and look actively at alternatives. The OHRC says the employee should make their needs known to the best of their ability, answer questions about limitations and take part in discussions, but is not responsible for originating a solution: that falls to the accommodation provider. Third, put the plan in writing and put it in place in a timely way. The CHRC says the plan is written with the worker and signed by all parties, and that the employer gives written reasons for any refusal; the OHRC says the provider bears the cost of the accommodation and of required medical documentation.
Fourth, keep a record, review the plan at agreed dates and keep it confidential. The OHRC says documentation should go only to people who need it, such as HR rather than a supervisor, and the CHRC says accommodation records belong in a file separate from the personnel file.
What does an accommodation change for the rest of the team?
It can move work, and the OHRC's policy speaks to privacy and to the tension that can follow. The OHRC says co-workers may have a role in helping with an accommodation, that care must be taken not to reveal more information than is necessary so the person is not singled out, and that the provider should take steps to resolve tension or conflict from resentment among those expected to help. The forms of accommodation the OHRC lists, such as modifying job duties and job bundling, mean that duties go somewhere else, which is OHA's reading and not the OHRC's.
In OHA's framework that is where load moves: cognitive and decisional load for whoever picks up the duties, and emotional load for the manager who holds the plan and the team's questions. The check above puts the Five Loads side by side for you or for your team. Accommodation on return from a leave is a separate subject, covered in our post on return to work after mental health leave in Ontario.
What OHA does about this
OHA's work with managers is built to measure the Five Loads a manager carries, including the emotional load of holding a plan and the team's questions, and is designed to help managers act on the heaviest one. The measurement is repeated at 90 days inside OHA's Capacity Circle™. To see how OHA works with managers, read about equipping managers to lead under pressure.
Sources
- Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability, 27 June 2016 (section 8, Duty to accommodate).
- Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on preventing discrimination based on mental health..., 2014 (section 13, Duty to accommodate; released 18 June 2014).
- Government of Canada, Canadian Human Rights Act, section 15, Current to 30 September 2026.
- Canadian Human Rights Commission, Workplace accommodation: A guide for federally regulated workplaces, 23 March 2026.
- Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability, 27 June 2016 (section 9, Undue hardship).
- Ontario Human Rights Commission, OHRC policy position on medical documentation to be provided, 2024 (page dated by its 2024 copyright).



