Skip to content
OHA

Short-term disability in Ontario is a plan, not a law

In OHA's reading, short-term disability in Ontario is a plan benefit that some employers provide, not something the ESA requires. How it sits next to ESA leave, EI sickness benefits and WSIB, what a manager does when an employee moves onto it, and what an absence costs.

, OHA Wellness

Published · Updated · Practice · 6 min

An employee and HR professional reviewing benefit forms
Short-term disability is a plan benefit; the ESA protects the job but does not pay, and the manager's part is the contact and the cover, not the diagnosis.

The short answer

Short-term disability is a benefit some employers provide under a plan. The ESA's sick leave and long-term illness leave protect the job but are unpaid, so the plan sets who qualifies, for how long and for how much.

On this page
  1. Is short-term disability required by law in Ontario?
  2. How does short-term disability fit with ESA leave, EI and WSIB?
  3. What does an absence cost an employer?
  4. What does a manager do when an employee moves to short-term disability?
  5. What does a disability claim not show about the team?
  6. What OHA does about this
  7. Sources

In OHA's reading, short-term disability in Ontario is a plan benefit, not a law: the Employment Standards Act (ESA) protects the job during a sick leave or a long-term illness leave but does not pay for either, and Canada.ca notes that some employers provide their own paid sick leave or short-term disability plan. Who qualifies, for how long and at what rate is therefore set by the employer's plan.

This post sets out how that benefit sits next to ESA leave, EI sickness benefits and WSIB, what a manager does when an employee moves from sick days to a disability claim, and what the absence costs. It is information from government and public sources, not legal advice: for a plan dispute or a contract question, call the plan's insurer or an employment lawyer.

Is short-term disability required by law in Ontario?

Neither ESA sick leave nor long-term illness leave pays a benefit. Sick leave is up to 3 unpaid days a year, and long-term illness leave is an unpaid, job-protected leave of up to 27 weeks in a 52-week period; the guide says employers do not have to pay wages during it. A short-term disability plan is a plan some employers provide.

Federally, Canada.ca describes an employer-side program tied to these plans. Employers with a qualifying short-term disability plan may pay EI premiums at a rate lower than the standard employer rate. A qualifying plan must provide at least 15 weeks of benefits, pay within 8 days of illness or injury with an elimination period of no more than 7 consecutive days, let employees claim within 3 months of hiring, match or exceed EI benefit levels and cover employees 24 hours a day.

How does short-term disability fit with ESA leave, EI and WSIB?

They answer different questions. The ESA guide says an employee may be entitled to more than one leave for the same event and that each leave is separate. In OHA's reading, the leave decides whether the job is protected, and the plan, EI or both decide whether pay continues. ESA sick leave protects up to 3 days a year. Long-term illness leave protects up to 27 weeks in 52 and needs a certificate from a qualified health practitioner that states a serious medical condition and the period away from work.

EI sickness benefits pay up to 26 weeks, 55% of earnings up to a maximum of $729 a week, as Canada.ca states it today. WSIB is a different system. It covers chronic or traumatic mental stress only when a qualified health professional has diagnosed it using the DSM-5 and work is the primary cause, and it generally does not cover stress caused by an employer's management decisions, such as firing, transfers, schedule changes or workload adjustments. Our post on what WSIB chronic mental stress covers and leaves out sets out the policy.

The Mental Health Commission of Canada's report published in 2013 says mental health problems and illnesses account for approximately 30% of short- and long-term disability claims; the page warns that the data may be out of date.

What does an absence cost an employer?

Nationally, the Institute for Work & Health's June 2026 summary of the CSA Group report The economic cost of mental health in Canada puts the annual cost of mental health challenges in Canada at an estimated CAD 180 billion, with employers and businesses bearing more than half. Of that, CAD 106 billion covers disability claims, mental health insurance premiums, group benefits, wage replacement, workplace accommodations and related expenses, and CAD 17 billion is productivity loss, mostly from presenteeism.

The absence itself is not rare. In Statistics Canada's April 2023 survey, 7.5% of employed people had taken time off from their job or business because of stress or for mental health reasons in the previous 12 months, an average of 2.4 days lost across all employed people.

For one organization, those national figures say little. The direct cost is the salary paid for days not worked, plus plan premiums and the cost of cover, and the calculator below works from your own headcount, salary and absence days to give a range.

Burnout cost calculator · 2 minutes

Put a number on lost capacity.

Your headcount, salaries and absence data give a yearly cost range, with every assumption shown. Put in your headcount, average salary and absence days. The result is a range for the year, with its assumptions beside it.

Step 1 of 2 · Your organization

Full-time equivalent, 5 to 100,000.
Gross salary, 20,000 to 500,000.

What does a manager do when an employee moves to short-term disability?

Start with the plan, not the diagnosis. Find out who in your organization handles claims, which dates and forms the plan needs and what the employer must supply. In many organizations HR or benefits handles the plan and the manager supplies factual information about the job; that is OHA's reading, so confirm it for your own plan. Keep medical detail with those who need it: the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) says documentation should go only to people who need it, such as HR rather than a supervisor, and that medical information should be kept separate from personnel files.

Where you do ask the employee for something, ask about function, not diagnosis. The OHRC says the focus should be on functional limitations rather than a person's diagnosis, and lists regular updates on the expected return among the information that supporting documentation should include for a person on leave. Agree with the employee and HR how often to be in touch, and keep the contact to the job and the return. The ESA guide adds that an employer cannot threaten, fire or penalize an employee for taking or planning to take a sick leave or a long-term illness leave.

Plan the work as for any absence of unknown length: list what must continue, what can wait and who covers each item, and review the list when the expected return date is known. When the benefit ends or the person is ready to come back, accommodation on return is a separate duty, covered in our post on return to work after mental health leave in Ontario.

What does a disability claim not show about the team?

It shows one person's absence and, in time, its cost. In OHA's reading it does not show the load that built before the claim or the load the team carries during it: work moves to colleagues, decisions wait on the manager, and the claim form records neither. OHA's framework separates the Five Loads (decisional, cognitive, emotional, relational and administrative) so that each can be read on its own. The pattern is the signal worth reading: several leaves or claims on one team, or cover work that sits on one or two people.

What OHA does about this

Short-term disability responds to an absence. OHA's Capacity Diagnostic is built to measure the Five Loads by team, so that HR can see which team carries the heaviest load and which load is behind it. It is designed to help leaders choose one change to make, and the measurement is repeated at 90 days inside OHA's Capacity Circle™. See how to book a Capacity Diagnostic.

Book a Capacity Diagnostic

Sources

  1. Government of Ontario, Sick leave, Your guide to the Employment Standards Act, Updated 5 February 2026.
  2. Government of Ontario, Long-term illness leave, Your guide to the Employment Standards Act, Updated 9 January 2026.
  3. Government of Canada, EI sickness benefits: What these benefits offer, Page dated 22 October 2026.
  4. Government of Canada, EI Premium Reduction Program: For employers, Page dated 27 October 2026.
  5. WSIB, Work-related mental stress injuries, Updated 26 March 2026.
  6. Mental Health Commission of Canada, Making the Case for Investing in Mental Health in Canada, 2013 (published 2013; the page says the data may be out of date).
  7. Institute for Work & Health, Mental health challenges cost employers over $100 billion a year, June 2026.
  8. Statistics Canada, Work-related stress most often caused by heavy workloads and work-life balance, 19 June 2023 (April 2023 data).
  9. Ontario Human Rights Commission, Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability, 27 June 2016 (section 8.8).
  10. Ontario Human Rights Commission, OHRC policy position on medical documentation to be provided, 2024 (page dated by its 2024 copyright).

Find out what is consuming your managers' capacity.

Tell us what your team needs. Caroline replies within one business day, in English or French.

We use these details only to answer your request. Privacy policy